Κυβερνοασφάλεια και ηλεκτρονική απάτη fp 1

Online banking fraud has become an increasingly significant legal issue as electronic payments and digital banking services continue to expand. Fraudsters may use deceptive emails, text messages, fraudulent websites or telephone calls to obtain banking credentials and cause the transfer of funds from other people’s accounts.

But what happens when the account holder requests reimbursement and the bank refuses, arguing that the transaction was authenticated through its security systems or that the customer was responsible?

Under Greek law, the answer depends on whether the payment was legally authorised, the circumstances surrounding the transaction and the applicable rules governing liability.

When Is an Online Banking Transaction Considered Unauthorised?

Greek Law 4537/2018, which transposed the EU’s Second Payment Services Directive (PSD2), provides that a payment transaction is authorised only where the payer has given consent to its execution in the agreed manner.

The use of login credentials, one-time passwords (OTPs) or other authentication methods does not necessarily establish, on its own, that the account holder authorised the particular transaction.

The legal assessment must therefore consider how the transfer was initiated, what actions were taken by the account holder and whether the required consent was provided.

A distinction must also be drawn between transactions carried out without the payer’s authorisation and payments that the payer personally instructed after being deceived by a fraudster.

The latter do not automatically qualify as unauthorised transactions and may require a different legal analysis.

Who Bears the Burden of Proof?

Where a payment service user denies authorising an executed transaction, Article 72 of Greek Law 4537/2018 establishes specific evidential obligations.

The relevant payment service provider must prove that the transaction was authenticated, accurately recorded, entered into the relevant accounts and not affected by a technical breakdown or another deficiency in the payment service.

However, successful technical authentication does not necessarily constitute sufficient proof that the payer authorised the transaction.

Furthermore, where fraud or gross negligence on the part of the user is alleged, the payment service provider must produce supporting evidence.

This distinction is particularly important in phishing cases, where fraudsters may exploit genuine banking systems and authentication procedures.

Is the Bank Required to Refund an Unauthorised Transaction?

Under the general rule established by Article 73 of Greek Law 4537/2018, a payment service provider must refund the amount of an unauthorised payment transaction immediately and, in any event, no later than the end of the following business day after becoming aware of or being notified of the transaction.

This obligation is subject to the applicable statutory requirements and exceptions, including circumstances involving reasonable grounds for suspecting fraud, where the provider makes the required written notification to the competent authority.

Accordingly, not every case of online banking fraud automatically gives rise to an unconditional right to reimbursement.

The legal classification of the payment and the specific circumstances of the case are essential in determining whether the statutory reimbursement obligations apply.

Can the Customer Be Held Liable for the Loss?

Greek law provides specific rules allocating liability for unauthorised payment transactions.

As a general rule, where losses arise from the use of a lost, stolen or misappropriated payment instrument, the payer’s liability may be limited to €50, subject to the requirements and exceptions set out in Article 74 of Greek Law 4537/2018.

An important amendment introduced by Greek Law 5019/2023, effective from 1 September 2023, concerns cases involving gross negligence.

Where the payer is a consumer and the losses result from gross negligence, the legislation provides, in principle, for a maximum liability of €1,000.

However, this limitation is not unconditional.

In particular, the €1,000 limitation does not apply where the payment service provider proves that it has implemented additional, effective and more sophisticated transaction-monitoring mechanisms beyond those used for strong customer authentication, for transactions capable of causing losses exceeding €1,000.

Separate rules apply where the payer has acted fraudulently.

Consequently, a bank’s allegation of gross negligence does not, by itself, determine the customer’s liability.

The relevant conduct, available evidence and statutory requirements must be examined in each individual case.

What Should You Do After Discovering a Suspicious Transaction?

Prompt action can be essential both to limiting further financial loss and to preserving legal rights.

The account holder should contact the bank or relevant payment service provider without undue delay, using an official communication channel, report the suspicious activity and request appropriate measures to protect the account or payment instrument.

Any transactions that were not authorised should be expressly disputed.

It is also important to preserve available evidence, including bank statements, transaction records, emails, messages and correspondence with the bank.

Depending on the circumstances, reporting the incident to the competent law enforcement authorities may also be appropriate. Such a report does not replace the obligation to notify the payment service provider promptly.

What Is the Deadline for Notifying the Bank?

Under Article 71 of Greek Law 4537/2018, payment service users must notify their payment service provider without undue delay upon becoming aware of an unauthorised or incorrectly executed payment transaction and, as a general rule, no later than 13 months after the debit date.

This period does not apply where the provider failed to supply or make available the legally required information concerning the transaction.

For non-consumer users, different notification periods may be contractually agreed, subject to the applicable statutory provisions, including the special protection afforded to microenterprises.

The 13-month period is not a general limitation period for bringing legal proceedings and should not be treated as a reason to postpone reporting the incident.

Notification should be made as soon as the user becomes aware of the disputed transaction.

What If the Bank Rejects Your Refund Request?

A bank’s refusal to reimburse a disputed transaction does not necessarily mean that the customer has no further legal options.

The reasons given for the refusal, the available transaction records, the customer’s conduct and the security measures actually applied are all relevant to the legal assessment.

Depending on the circumstances, further out-of-court procedures or civil proceedings may be considered.

Additional claims for damages or non-pecuniary harm require a separate legal basis and satisfaction of the applicable legal requirements. They do not arise automatically from every incident of online banking fraud.

Frequently Asked Questions About Phishing and Unauthorised Payments in Greece

Does entering an OTP mean that I authorised the transaction?

Not necessarily. The use of an OTP or another authentication method is not, by itself, conclusive proof of authorisation in every case. The circumstances and available evidence must be assessed.

Can a bank refuse reimbursement because I was grossly negligent?

A claim of gross negligence requires legal and factual assessment. Greek law contains a specific €1,000 liability limitation for consumers, but this is subject to a significant statutory exception.

Can I recover money transferred as a result of phishing?

Potentially, depending on whether the transaction was legally authorised and whether the applicable requirements for reimbursement or other forms of liability are satisfied.

Do the same protections apply to personal and business bank accounts?

Not necessarily. The applicable rules may differ depending on the user’s legal status, the specific protections afforded to microenterprises and any contractual derogations permitted by law.

Conclusion

Phishing and online banking fraud disputes require more than a review of whether the correct security credentials were used.

The existence of valid authorisation, the available evidence and the statutory allocation of liability are central to determining whether reimbursement may be legally pursued.

Prompt reporting, preservation of evidence and an individual legal assessment are essential when considering the available remedies under Greek law.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute individual legal advice. Each case requires a separate assessment of its specific circumstances, the date of the relevant transactions and the applicable legal framework. For an individual legal assessment of your case, you may contact our law firm.

No comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *